Hotels in Monticello (Indiana, USA)

How payments to us affect ranking

130 hotels in Monticello

    Best Western Plus Brandywine Inn & Suites

    3 Stars

    Heated indoor pool and hot tub, Wellness area with sauna and massage

    See prices from 15 sites
    from  $128

    Monticello Inn

    2 Stars

    Seasonal outdoor swimming pool, On-site family restaurant

    Select dates to see exact prices

    Alexanders Landing

    Heated indoor swimming pool, Outdoor hot tub with lake views

    See prices from 7 sites
    from  $180

  4. Dockside Lake Resort

    2 Stars

    Seasonal heated outdoor pool, Lake Shafer dock access

    Select dates to see exact prices

  5. Indiana Beach Hotel and Banquet Hall

    2 Stars
    Select dates to see exact prices

  6. Blue Door Cottages

    Select dates to see exact prices

  7. Pine View Resort

    4 Stars
    Select dates to see exact prices

  8. Indiana Beach Hotel

    3 Stars

    Seasonal outdoor swimming pool, Proximity to Indiana Beach Amusement Resort

    Select dates to see exact prices

  9. Serene Waterfront Monticello House with Fire Pit!

    Select dates to see exact prices

  10. Cozy Cottage with Private Patio Near Indiana Beach!

    Select dates to see exact prices

  12. Escape To Lakefront Luxury: Cozy 1-bedroom Rv At Lake Shafers Edge!

    Select dates to see exact prices

  13. The Main Lake House - Lake Front - Lake Freeman - Patio, Fire Pit , Dock, Grill

    Select dates to see exact prices

  14. Peaceful Waterfront Home - Close To Indiana Beach

    Select dates to see exact prices

  15. Lucretias Lakeside

    Select dates to see exact prices

  16. Firefly At Lake Shafer

    Select dates to see exact prices

  17. 3 Bedroom Suite, Just Steps From Indiana Beach With Lake Access And More!

    Select dates to see exact prices

  18. Lake Front Room At Lake Shafer, Just Steps From Indiana Beach

    Select dates to see exact prices

  19. 2br Room At Alexander’s Landing. Walk To Indiana Beach + Pool Access

    Select dates to see exact prices

  20. Alexander’s Landing Penthouse - Lakefront, Balcony, And Room To Relax

    Select dates to see exact prices

  21. Waterfront Tippecanoe River and Lake Freeman

    Select dates to see exact prices

  22. Lakeside Bliss: Spectacular Lake Views And Access!

    Select dates to see exact prices

  23. 2-bdrm, 7 bed Lakefront Cottage 9 mi to Indiana Beach 27 mi to Purdue

    Select dates to see exact prices

  24. Relaxing Lakefront Escape on Lake Shafer

    Select dates to see exact prices

  25. Charming 3-bedroom House Across From Lake Freeman

    Select dates to see exact prices

  26. A Peaceful Retreat, Comfortable Environment To Relax On Lake Shafer

    Select dates to see exact prices

  27. Waterfront 2BR Cottage: Fire Pit, Grill & Dock -Boat Slip Available additional

    Select dates to see exact prices

  28. Indiana Beach Rentals On Shafer Lake, Monticello

    Select dates to see exact prices

  29. Lake Shafer Home: Boat, Swim, Kayak, Bbq, Sunsets, Ten Minutes To Indiana Beach

    Select dates to see exact prices

  30. Lakehouse With A Private Beach

    Select dates to see exact prices

  31. Pirates Cove Resort

    3 Stars
    Select dates to see exact prices

  32. Newly Remodeled Home on Lake Shafer with 120 Ft of Waterfront

    Select dates to see exact prices

  33. Amazing Lakefront House With All The Amenities!

    Select dates to see exact prices

  34. Key Lime Resorts - Unit #5 - 5 Oclock Somewhere Lake House

    Select dates to see exact prices

  35. Lake Freeman House W/boat Dock... Minutes From Indiana Beach/lake Shafer

    Select dates to see exact prices

  36. Adorable Lake House On Lake Shafer With Two Family Rooms And Optional Pontoon!

    Select dates to see exact prices

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Other stays in Monticello

Popular hotel categories in Monticello

When to book a hotel in Monticello

  • Cheapest month: March
    $142 per night
  • Yearly typical price
    $160 per night
  • Peak month: May
    $241 per night

Frequently Asked Questions about Monticello

  • When is the cheapest time to book a hotel in Monticello?

    March is usually the cheapest month to book a hotel in Monticello, with typical prices around $142 per night based on 37 price comparisons.

  • When are hotel prices highest in Monticello?

    Hotel prices in Monticello are usually highest during May, with typical prices around $241 per night.

  • How much does a hotel in Monticello cost per night?

    Hotel prices in Monticello usually range from $140 per night to $302 per night, with typical prices around $160 per night.

  • How do hotel prices in Monticello change throughout the year?

    Hotel prices in Monticello are typically lowest in March at around $142 per night, rising to around $241 per night in May.

  • October

    2026

    $212
    $169 — $278

  • November

    2026

    $181
    $145 — $277

  • December

    2026

    $170
    $169 — $229

  • January

    2027

    $157
    $145 — $181

  • February

    2027

    $160
    $154 — $190

  • March

    2027

    $142
    $140 — $166

  • April

    2027

    $154
    $152 — $190

  • May

    2027

    $241
    $214 — $302

  • June

    2027

    $157
    $157 — $187

  • July

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • August

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • September

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

Frequently Asked Questions about Monticello

Hotels in Monticello

These hotels may also be interesting for you...

Points of Interest - Monticello

Top Destinations

More Top Destinations

See all stays in Monticello