Hotel Sutter

This historic hotel is celebrated for its exceptional dining and bar experience, which many guests consider a primary reason to visit and return. Its charming ambiance and central location in a quaint town make it an ideal destination for couples seeking a romantic getaway, food enthusiasts looking for culinary delights, and sightseers exploring the historic Gold Country. Guests consistently highlight the friendly staff, the quality of the food, and the hotel's beautifully updated historic charm. To make the most of your stay, consider making dinner reservations due to the restaurant's popularity, and plan to explore the surrounding town on foot, as many attractions are easily accessible.

Facilities & Amenities
The hotel offers a range of appealing facilities, most notably its multiple bars, including a popular speakeasy known as the Copper Room, which provides a unique and lively atmosphere for drinks. Guests appreciate the convenience of having these vibrant social spaces directly on-site. An upstairs balcony offers a pleasant view and is a favored spot for dining or relaxing. While the hotel maintains its historic charm, it has been thoughtfully updated with modern touches. An elevator is available, though some guests note its slow pace, adding to the hotel's quirky character. The overall impression is one of comfort and convenience, with well-maintained common areas that enhance the guest experience.

Cleanliness & Room Comfort
Guests generally find the rooms to be clean and well-maintained, reflecting the hotel's commitment to hygiene. However, feedback on bed comfort is mixed, with some guests praising them as very comfortable, while others found them uncomfortable or too soft, occasionally affecting sleep quality. Room sizes vary, with some guests noting their rooms felt small or even claustrophobic, while others enjoyed spacious accommodations. The bathrooms are frequently described as modern and updated, though some have unique features like separate hot and cold faucets or glass shelves that can be inconvenient. Noise can be an issue, with reports of street noise, sounds from the bar below, and general noise levels from other guests or gurgling pipes, particularly in rooms located above the bar or near busy areas.

Dining & Food Quality
The hotel's restaurant and bars receive overwhelmingly positive reviews, consistently praised for their superb food quality and vibrant atmosphere. Many guests describe their meals as "delicious" and "culinary perfection," with standout dishes including Mahi Mahi, beef ribs, filet mignon, salmon, and roasted brussel sprouts. The cocktail selection is also highly rated, with bartenders noted for their skill. While the dinner and lunch experiences are a major highlight, feedback on breakfast is more varied; some guests found it good or adequate, while others expressed disappointment or noted its absence, with the restaurant typically opening later for lunch. The overall dining experience is a significant draw, making reservations highly recommended.

Location & Accessibility
The hotel boasts an unbeatable central location directly on Main Street in downtown Sutter Creek, placing guests within easy walking distance of numerous shops, restaurants, wine tasting rooms, and the Sutter Theatre. This prime position allows guests to fully immerse themselves in the charming, historic atmosphere of the town and explore nearby attractions like the Knight Foundry and Gold Country towns. Parking is available, with options for free parking in a lot behind the hotel or on the street. However, parking can be limited and challenging to find, especially during busy periods, sometimes requiring guests to park a few blocks away.

Staff & Service
The staff consistently receives high praise for their friendliness, helpfulness, and accommodating service. Guests frequently highlight the warm welcome, attentiveness, and professional demeanor of the team, from the front desk to the restaurant and bar staff. The check-in process is generally described as easy and efficient. Many reviews specifically commend the restaurant and bar staff for their exceptional service, making dining experiences memorable. The staff's willingness to go the extra mile to ensure guest comfort and satisfaction is a recurring theme, contributing significantly to the positive overall impression of the hotel.

Additional Information
This hotel, housed in a historic building dating back to 1858, beautifully blends its original charm with modern updates, offering a unique "old town feel." A notable and often-mentioned feature is the Copper Room, a popular speakeasy-style bar located in the basement, providing a distinct and enjoyable experience. Guests appreciate the hotel's pet-friendly policy, allowing them to bring their companions. Some guests have noted the absence of certain in-room amenities like mini-fridges or microwaves, which can impact convenience for longer stays. The hotel also features a charming anecdote about its elevator, humorously compared to a tortoise due to its deliberate pace, adding to the property's character.