3 Stars
Select dates to see exact prices
Select dates to see exact prices
  • reception
  • bedroom

1 / 99

Good to know

  • Relax at seasonal outdoor pool

    Relax at the seasonal outdoor pool and adjacent hot tub, which remain open for guest use during warmer months.

  • Walk to downtown Edgartown shops

    Walk just minutes to reach the Edgartown waterfront, local shops, and ferry terminals from this central location.

  • No elevator access in buildings

    Guest rooms are spread across multiple buildings, none of which feature elevator access for luggage or guests.

  • Dine at on-site Pelican Club

    Dine at the on-site Pelican Club, which offers sushi and cocktails in a trendy atmosphere.

  • Enjoy curated in-room vinyl records

    Enjoy curated in-room vinyl records on provided turntables, a signature feature found in many guest rooms.

  • Potential noise from property facilities

    Some guest rooms may experience noise or vibrations from the on-site gym or the Pelican Club bar area.

  • Limited on-site parking availability

    On-site parking is extremely limited, and guests may need to utilize overflow lots located several blocks away.

This summary was created by AI and might not be 100% accurate.

Rooms

  • Suite, 1 Bedroom, Kitchen (Chappy House)

    • 1 1 King Bed
    • Sleeps 2
    • 534 sq ft
  • Suite, 3 Bedrooms (Mizzentop)

    • 1 1 Double Sofa Bed, 1 King Bed and 1 Twin Bed
    • Sleeps 5
    • 854 sq ft
  • Suite, 2 Bedrooms, Kitchen (Wheel House)

    • 1 2 Queen Beds
    • Sleeps 4
    • 1139 sq ft
  • Suite, 2 Bedrooms (Chappy House)

    • 1 1 King Bed and 2 Queen Beds
    • Sleeps 6
    • 676 sq ft

Compare with similar stays

Selected stay

3 Stars

  • WiFi
  • Pool
  • Parking
Select dates to see exact prices

Similar stays

  • 4 Stars

    • WiFi
    • A/C
    See prices from 6 sites
    from$246
  • 4 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Spa
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 5 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Parking
    See prices from 13 sites
    from$445
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Parking
    • A/C
    See prices from 8 sites
    from$234
    • WiFi
    • Parking
    • Pets
    See prices from 4 sites
    from$251
  • 4 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Spa
    • Parking
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 4 Stars

    • WiFi
    • A/C
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Parking
    • A/C
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Spa
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • A/C
    See prices from 4 sites
    from$309
  • 4 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Parking
    • A/C
    See prices from 5 sites
    from$495

Price trend

Based on lowest prices on trivago from the last 30 days
$479
$240
$0

Sun, 11/22/26

$335

Mon, 11/23/26

$323

Tue, 11/24/26

$304

Wed, 11/25/26

$452

Thu, 11/26/26

$479

Fri, 11/27/26

$452

Sat, 11/28/26

$452

Sun, 11/29/26

$333

Mon, 11/30/26

$325

Tue, 12/01/26

N/A

Wed, 12/02/26

N/A

Thu, 12/03/26

N/A

Fri, 12/04/26

N/A

Sat, 12/05/26

N/A

Sun, 12/06/26

N/A

Mon, 12/07/26

N/A

Tue, 12/08/26

N/A

Wed, 12/09/26

N/A

Thu, 12/10/26

N/A

Fri, 12/11/26

N/A

Sat, 12/12/26

N/A

Sun, 12/13/26

N/A

Mon, 12/14/26

N/A

Tue, 12/15/26

N/A

Wed, 12/16/26

N/A

Thu, 12/17/26

N/A

Fri, 12/18/26

N/A

Sat, 12/19/26

N/A

Sun, 12/20/26

N/A

Mon, 12/21/26

N/A

Tue, 12/22/26

N/A

Wed, 12/23/26

N/A

Thu, 12/24/26

N/A

Fri, 12/25/26

N/A

Sat, 12/26/26

N/A

Sun, 12/27/26

N/A

Mon, 12/28/26

N/A

Tue, 12/29/26

N/A

Wed, 12/30/26

N/A

Thu, 12/31/26

N/A

Fri, 01/01/27

N/A

Sat, 01/02/27

N/A

Sun, 01/03/27

N/A

Mon, 01/04/27

N/A

Tue, 01/05/27

N/A

Wed, 01/06/27

N/A

Thu, 01/07/27

N/A

Fri, 01/08/27

N/A

Sat, 01/09/27

N/A

Sun, 01/10/27

N/A

Mon, 01/11/27

N/A

Reviews

8.8
Excellent
based on 2,128 ratings from top 
sites
sites

Review summary

Summarized by AI from 300+ reviews

This hotel is a tranquil historic hideaway perfect for couples and sightseers seeking a charming island escape. Its ideal and central location in Edgartown provides effortless walking access to shops, dining, and the picturesque waterfront. The highlight among its amenities is the beautiful and large swimming pool and hot tub, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploration. Guests consistently praise the friendly and helpful staff and enjoy the charming on-site pub, The Newes from America, with its cozy wood-burning fireplace. For a unique touch, consider booking a room with a turntable and album collection for a nostalgic stay.

Rated above average for Martha's Vineyard

Guest reviews

Excellent68%
Very good13%
Good7%
Fair5%
Poor7%

Top amenities

  • WiFi
  • Pool
  • Parking
  • A/C
  • Restaurant
  • Hotel bar

All amenities

Property amenities

  • Business centre
  • Café
  • Entrance hall/lobby
  • Express check-in/check-out

Wellness

  • Massage

Room amenities

  • Ironing board
  • Openable windows
  • Television
  • Central heating

Sports facilities

  • Golf course
  • Fitness

Hotel characteristics

  • Family friendly

Location

23 Kelly St, Martha's Vineyard, 02539, USA

Highlight

Walk to downtown Edgartown shops

Walk just minutes to reach the Edgartown waterfront, local shops, and ferry terminals from this central location.

Distance from Faraway Martha's Vineyard

  1. 0.4 km from Edgartown Village Historic District
  2. 0.4 km from Doctor Daniel Fisher House Museum
  3. 8.2 km from Featherstone Center for the Arts
  4. 8.3 km from Campgrounds
  5. 8.4 km from Flying Horses Carousel
  6. 10.7 km from William Street Historic District
  7. 12.8 km from Martha's Vineyard (City centre)
  8. 13.9 km from Polly Hill Arboretum
  9. 19.4 km from Marina Park Amphitheater
  10. 20.5 km from Falmouth Museums on the Green
  11. 35.3 km from Hyannis
  12. 85 km from Rhode Island T. F. Green International Airport

Explore nearby attractions

Property info

23 Kelly St, Martha's Vineyard, 02539, USA

Frequently Asked Questions about Faraway Martha's Vineyard

Is there a pool area at Faraway Martha's Vineyard?

Yes, Faraway Martha's Vineyard offers 2 pool areas.

Are pets allowed at Faraway Martha's Vineyard?

No, Faraway Martha's Vineyard doesn’t allow pets.

Is parking available at Faraway Martha's Vineyard?

Yes, Faraway Martha's Vineyard provides Parking for guests.

What time is check-in and check-out at Faraway Martha's Vineyard?

Check-in at Faraway Martha's Vineyard is available from: . Check-out time is by .

Where is Faraway Martha's Vineyard located?

Faraway Martha's Vineyard is located in 23 Kelly St, 02539, Martha's Vineyard, USA.

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Among Top Rated Hotels in Martha's Vineyard

  • 3 Stars
    The Lightkeepers Inn
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars
    Inn on the Square
    See prices from 8 sites
    from$173
  • 4 Stars
    Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars
    The Christopher
    See prices from 4 sites
    from$309
  • Falmouth Tides
    See prices from 4 sites
    from$251
  • 3 Stars
    Island Inn
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 2 Stars
    Harbor Landing Resort
    Select dates to see exact prices

Destinations near Faraway Martha's Vineyard