Commodore Suites

This hotel offers a highly convenient and central experience, distinguished by its location directly above a well-stocked supermarket and its inviting rooftop pool and jacuzzi area, which provides captivating views. Guests consistently highlight the hotel's excellent central location, placing them within easy reach of beaches, diverse dining options, and vibrant nightlife. The spacious rooms, often equipped with kitchenettes, are frequently appreciated. While the friendly and helpful staff receive widespread praise, some guests note inconsistencies in maintenance and housekeeping. This hotel is particularly well-suited for business travelers, solo travelers, and couples seeking a practical and lively base for exploring the island's entertainment and culinary scene. For an enhanced stay, guests might consider inquiring about housekeeping frequency upon arrival and requesting a room away from the street if sensitive to evening noise.

Facilities & Amenities
Guests appreciate the convenience of the hotel's rooftop pool and jacuzzi, which offer pleasant views and a relaxing atmosphere, though some note the pool is more akin to a large hot tub. An outdoor gym with unique equipment is also available for guest use. Many rooms feature practical kitchenettes, including a microwave and refrigerator, with some also offering cooking facilities, though the supply of kitchenware can be minimal. While free Wi-Fi is provided, some guests report inconsistent connectivity. The presence of an elevator is valued, but it is frequently reported as being out of service, requiring guests to use stairs. Other amenities include ice machines, vending machines, and the provision of beach towels and hairdryers upon request. A safe is available in rooms, though its placement can be awkward. The hotel also offers a popular happy hour with complimentary drinks on the rooftop.

Cleanliness & Room Comfort
Rooms are generally described as spacious and clean, with many guests praising the comfortable beds and large bathrooms featuring modern designs. The air conditioning is consistently noted as effective, providing a cool environment. However, some guests have reported issues with a musty smell or humidity in rooms, often attributed to windows that do not open, which can also make rooms feel dark. There are recurring comments about maintenance issues, such as chipped doors, loose toilet seats, broken faucets, cracked induction stoves, and refrigerators that do not close properly. Dust and breadcrumbs have been observed in some areas, and lighting can be insufficient due to dark paint or broken fixtures. Noise from construction or nearby nightlife can occasionally impact comfort. Housekeeping consistency is a concern for some, with reports of infrequent service, unemptied trash, and unchanged towels.

Dining & Food Quality
The hotel does not feature a traditional on-site restaurant or dedicated breakfast area, but its location directly above the Market Garden supermarket is a significant advantage. This supermarket offers a wide array of fresh produce, specialty coffees, and breakfast pastries, along with gluten-free and lactose-free options, allowing guests to easily purchase items for in-room preparation. Some rooms are equipped with Italian coffee machines, which are appreciated. While breakfast vouchers are offered, some guests find them confusing, noting that many items require additional payment. There is no room service for dining, but the convenient access to the supermarket and numerous nearby eateries mitigates this. The hotel also hosts a complimentary happy hour with drinks on the rooftop, which is a popular social offering.

Location & Accessibility
The hotel boasts an exceptional central location in Simpson Bay, making it a prime spot for exploring the area. Guests can easily walk to Kim Sha Beach within minutes, and a plethora of restaurants, bars, nightlife venues, and a casino are all within close proximity. Its position directly above a supermarket adds immense convenience for daily needs. The hotel is highly accessible via public transportation, with buses to and from the airport readily available and affordable. The airport itself is just a short 5 to 10-minute drive away. For those with maritime interests, the hotel is also conveniently located near the marina. While the vibrant nightlife is a major draw, some guests have noted that the area can be noisy at night, particularly for rooms facing the street.

Staff & Service
The friendly staff consistently receive high praise from guests, who describe them as helpful, attentive, accommodating, warm, and professional. Many reviews highlight the quick check-in process and the staff's willingness to go "above and beyond" to assist guests, whether by helping with ferry arrangements, providing gifts for special occasions, or facilitating early check-ins and late check-outs. Guests appreciate that dish soap and beach towels are provided upon request. However, a recurring concern is the housekeeping consistency, with some guests reporting that rooms are not cleaned daily, trash is not removed, and towels are not changed regularly. While the staff are generally lauded for their demeanor, some guests have noted instances where front desk personnel were perceived as absent or less proactive in resolving maintenance issues.

Additional Information
The hotel is described as a boutique hotel offering all suites with kitchens, providing a comfortable and practical stay. Guests frequently commend the overall value offered by the hotel, considering its amenities and prime location. A notable feature is the provision of free drinks on the rooftop terrace during a daily happy hour, creating a pleasant social atmosphere. Some rooms are characterized by a distinctive large circle window, adding to their modern aesthetic. While the hotel aims to provide a comprehensive experience, guests should be aware that some rooms may lack a balcony. The hotel's policy regarding laundry facilities is not explicitly detailed in reviews, but some guests have noted the absence of on-site clothes washing options, which could be a consideration for longer stays.